Animal’s Daily Electric Plane News

Before we get into this, check out the last chapter of Setting Suns over at Glibertarians.

Now then:  NASA has cancelled their electric plane project. Here’s why:

NASA said today in a conference call with reporters that it would not ever be flying its experimental electric aircraft, the X-57, citing safety concerns that are insurmountable with the time and budget they have for the project. The X-57 program will wind down without the aircraft ever going up into the sky. 

The agency had previously hoped to fly the aircraft, which would be powered by batteries and electric motors, sometime this year. While the original plans had called for the research plane to eventually have more than a dozen propellers, NASA had scaled back those plans too, intending to fly the plane in what they called Modification 2 form. Mod 2 involved the plane having just two propellers, with one on each wing. The news today means that the plane will never fly, not even in Mod 2 form. 

And:

The problem that led them to scrap the plan to fly the aircraft stemmed from motors that power the propellers. Clark said today that analysis of the issue is ongoing. “As we got into the detailed analysis and airworthiness assessment of the motors themselves, we found that there were some potential failure modes with the motors mechanically, under flight loads, that we hadn’t seen on the ground,” he said. “We’ve got a great design in progress to fix it, it’s just [that] it would take too long for us to go through and implement that.”

I’m not sure why NASA is spending (presumably) taxpayer dollars on this.  If there is a commercial market for an electric airplane, someone will develop one that works, and cash in.  If there isn’t a commercial market, then there’s no reason for NASA to be arsing around with it.

It’s difficult to understand what the taxpayers have to gain by indulging in this kind of work.  I’m certainly no Luddite, but we already have perfectly adequate aircraft technology, and improvements in existing turbofan engines make them more efficient all the time.  That is, by the way, resulting in making air travel and air shipments cheaper, too, although there’s also an element of ‘cramming more people into smaller seats’ on the travel side of that.

Markets, not governments, should decide if there is or is not a purpose for this sort of thing.